schmidt1024/monero-ecosystem
schmidt1024/monero-ecosystem
1
1
Fork 0
Code Issues 5 Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases 16 Wiki Activity

Add Coin Wallet #20

New Issue
Closed
opened 2025-03-11 14:22:27 +00:00 by schmidt1024 · 6 comments
schmidt1024 commented 2025-03-11 14:22:27 +00:00
Owner
Copy Link

Please add our wallet, we have a lot of Monero holders!

Coin Wallet - HOT wallet
https://coin.space
Square logo is ok

Src https://xcancel.com/CoinAppWallet/status/1899464452942287307

Please add our wallet, we have a lot of Monero holders! Coin Wallet - HOT wallet https://coin.space Square logo is ok Src https://xcancel.com/CoinAppWallet/status/1899464452942287307
schmidt1024 commented 2025-03-12 06:56:04 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

This proposal is something to discuss. Idk Coin Wallet and didn't hear about it in the X Monero community. Idk either, if it is accepted in the community. So let's do some research before adding it.

This proposal is something to discuss. Idk Coin Wallet and didn't hear about it in the X Monero community. Idk either, if it is accepted in the community. So let's do some research before adding it.
👍 1
mondetta commented 2025-03-13 13:23:42 +00:00
Collaborator
Copy Link

The main question is: What functionality does it offer as a wallet, that other known wallets don not have?
As far as I know the answer is none. Currently not considering adding it.

The main question is: What functionality does it offer as a wallet, that other known wallets don not have? As far as I know the answer is none. Currently not considering adding it.
mondetta commented 2025-03-18 21:44:40 +00:00
Collaborator
Copy Link

Tested Coin Wallet and it does not appear to offer unique features for Monero users. Therefore I vote against adding.

Tested Coin Wallet and it does not appear to offer unique features for Monero users. Therefore I vote against adding.
👍 1
schmidt1024 commented 2025-03-25 06:09:02 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

I don't think a wallet has to offer unique features for Monero users. Let's keep it open until I can test it myself.

I don't think a wallet has to offer unique features for Monero users. Let's keep it open until I can test it myself.
schmidt1024 commented 2025-03-28 09:28:51 +00:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

additional posts from coinwallet

Based on the wallets available, none of them offer a fully functional WEB wallet. This is quite rare for self-custodial wallets.

Additionally, we provide:

  • A stable Linux version (not beta) – via Snapcraft
  • A stable Windows version (not beta)
  • Tor Browser support
    Which other monero wallet offers this kind of setup?

src https://xcancel.com/CoinAppWallet/status/1901642223932043592

you don’t have to wait a week for your wallet to sync if you haven’t opened it in a year.
Most other wallets make you sit through a full sync.
And unlike Cake, we never send your 'private view key' to the server

src https://xcancel.com/CoinAppWallet/status/1905550954050846887

additional posts from coinwallet --- Based on the wallets available, none of them offer a fully functional WEB wallet. This is quite rare for self-custodial wallets. Additionally, we provide: - A stable Linux version (not beta) – via Snapcraft - A stable Windows version (not beta) - Tor Browser support Which other monero wallet offers this kind of setup? src https://xcancel.com/CoinAppWallet/status/1901642223932043592 --- you don’t have to wait a week for your wallet to sync if you haven’t opened it in a year. Most other wallets make you sit through a full sync. And unlike Cake, we never send your 'private view key' to the server src https://xcancel.com/CoinAppWallet/status/1905550954050846887
👍 1
mondetta commented 2025-03-31 20:56:54 +00:00
Collaborator
Copy Link

So glad I didn't have to write part of the investigation text myself. Thanks MoneroKon!
Coin Wallet claims :^)

  • Fully functional WEB wallet
  • Stable not beta
  • Stable not beta
  • Tor Browser support. Which other monero wallet offers this kind of setup?

In which (non-existent) scenario should a (new) Monero user use Coin Wallet?

  • Because of "stable, not beta" Linux wallet?
    -> Reminder: Feather wallet + Tor exists
  • Because of "stable, not beta" Windows wallet?
    -> Reminder: Feather wallet + Tor exists
  • Tor Browser support?
    -> We finally found (not) the most secure, reliable OPSEC tool for operating a fully functional Moreno wallet

During testing of the online/web wallet this week, several concerns were identified specifically with the Monero wallet integration:
Limited Subaddress Functionality
Only the public address and the first subaddress are accessible.
Missing Features: Ability to check or change to other subaddresses
Potential Update Issues
I attempted to transfer funds from other wallets, but I encountered potential issues with the web wallet, such as the funds or balance not updating. Additionally, I imported the private key into other wallets for verification and was able to see the updated balance.

src https://mattermost.monerokon.org/plugins/focalboard/team/7jxzshir6j895kwgu71mdx5xrc/shared/buntcef156pgp7fy6x5oyn33rny/vchn7j3cnkpnmiyczoqcbyizkcy/csiguq8exr7yj3yjdpthxuycc1y?r=k7drhyrbfygt844ejqb7h58o6dw

Cake Wallet has background sync.

src https://xcancel.com/cakewallet/status/1904574394657366273

Coin Wallet may improve and come back in x time. The issue will be closed for x time.

So glad I didn't have to write part of the investigation text myself. Thanks MoneroKon! Coin Wallet claims :^) - Fully functional WEB wallet - Stable not beta - Stable not beta - Tor Browser support. Which other monero wallet offers this kind of setup? In which (non-existent) scenario should a (new) Monero user use Coin Wallet? - Because of "stable, not beta" Linux wallet? -> Reminder: Feather wallet + Tor exists - Because of "stable, not beta" Windows wallet? -> Reminder: Feather wallet + Tor exists - Tor Browser support? -> We finally found (not) the most secure, reliable OPSEC tool for operating a fully functional Moreno wallet > During testing of the online/web wallet this week, several concerns were identified specifically with the Monero wallet integration: Limited Subaddress Functionality Only the public address and the first subaddress are accessible. Missing Features: Ability to check or change to other subaddresses Potential Update Issues I attempted to transfer funds from other wallets, but I encountered potential issues with the web wallet, such as the funds or balance not updating. Additionally, I imported the private key into other wallets for verification and was able to see the updated balance. src https://mattermost.monerokon.org/plugins/focalboard/team/7jxzshir6j895kwgu71mdx5xrc/shared/buntcef156pgp7fy6x5oyn33rny/vchn7j3cnkpnmiyczoqcbyizkcy/csiguq8exr7yj3yjdpthxuycc1y?r=k7drhyrbfygt844ejqb7h58o6dw > Cake Wallet has background sync. src https://xcancel.com/cakewallet/status/1904574394657366273 Coin Wallet may improve and come back in x time. The issue will be closed for x time.
🚀 1
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
No items
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
mondetta schmidt1024
No Assignees
2 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: schmidt1024/monero-ecosystem#20
No description provided.
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?